After more than 20 years of legal wrangles, controversial plans for a motorway service area (MSA) off the A1(M) in North Yorkshire are set to be given the go-ahead next week.
North Yorkshire Council planning officers are recommending approval of the reserved matters application for the Vale of York MSA at Kirby Hill, near Boroughbridge.
The proposal for the Welcome Break services has generated significant local opposition, with Boroughbridge Town Council, Kirby Hill and Marton-le-Moor Parish Council, Langthorpe Parish Council, Skelton-cum-Newby Parish Council and Roecliffe and Westwick Parish Council all objecting.
Objectors argue the latest plans go far beyond what was approved at outline stage, claiming the scheme has become more visually intrusive through a higher motorway bridge, larger embankments, expanded landscaping and additional drainage lagoons east of the A1(M).
Parish councils have described the changes as materially increasing the scale and impact of the development and say a fresh planning application, supported by a new environmental impact assessment, should have been submitted.
Concerns have also been raised over the omission of green roofs, the safety of the B6265 access, the visual impact on nearby Kirby Hill, the effect on groundwater because of the site’s position above a principal aquifer, and whether the development remains necessary given other motorway service facilities that have since been approved or expanded elsewhere on the A1(M).
More than 70 members of the public also submitted objections, raising fears over increased traffic, noise, light pollution and landscape harm.
However, planning officers conclude that the development remains broadly consistent with the outline permission and does not require a new environmental impact assessment.
They say a separate screening opinion found the changes are not so substantial that the existing environmental assessment can no longer be relied upon.
The report also rejects claims that green roofs have been removed, stating they remain part of the proposals, with wildflower roofs on the main amenity building and fuel station and sedum roofs on the drive-through coffee shop and HGV filling station.
Officers note that the bridge and eastern roundabout are higher than originally illustrated, but say the increases remain within the approved height parameters and were necessary to meet National Highways’ requirements for a single-span bridge capable of accommodating future vehicle heights.
They also point out that National Highways, the council’s highways authority, the Environment Agency, Yorkshire Water and the council’s ecologist have all raised no objections, subject to conditions where appropriate.
The service area would provide parking for 364 cars, 90 HGVs, 18 coaches, caravans and motorcycles, together with fuel filling stations, a drive-through coffee shop and amenity building.
Outline planning permission was granted for the MSA in 2021 following a public inquiry after more than 20 years of legal wrangles.
The application will be discussed by North Yorkshire Council’s strategic planning committee on Tuesday next week.
Be the first to comment